For Love of Crazy Mare Caerphilly

With Christmas closing in I chose Caerphilly to make for my challenge.  With my kids this is one of our favorite cheeses, and is usually made at our house with goat’s milk.  But since the goats are dry I had to find another milk source.  I used 16 liters of fresh, cow’s milk.  And when I say fresh I mean, not pasteurized and un-homogenized.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.


I’ve made this cheese so many times and it’s so enjoyable to see the curd form.  I loved working with the cow’s milk and can’t believe how great the yield was.  It actually makes me want a cow…again!  I had to use a lot of muscle to get the curds into the press and thank you to my photographer for capturing that moment of muscle!  After pressing for 30 minutes I took the cheese out of the press and redressed the block by gently rolling the cheese and wrapping in like a package, then back into the press for another 12 hours.  The next morning I removed the cheese from the press and trimmed off the extra cheese to make for smooth edges(this happens even in real artesian cheese shops), to prevent any cracking or edges for bacteria to enter the cheese.  Then it’s off to the brine.  I chose from experience to check the salinity and the ph of the brine prior to placing the cheese in and it’s a good thing because it needed salt and vinegar!  With this done 20 hours later, it was off to the dry mat.  I know that Mary’s recipe calls for drying and brushing to develop a rind but with the cheese being raw I chose to wrap it in cheese cloth and it will age for at least 60 days.


This cheese has always been a family favorite because of its mild taste it can be reminiscent of cheddar without all the work of the cheddar process.  Creamy and smooth in texture, with a small hint of salt because of the brine, I can’t wait to share the cutting of this aged cheese out of its wrappings!



  1. That is a great looking cheese. I have almost the same press, but I don’t have the gauge at the top. I think I am going to have to get one of those. I have never thought about bandaging a Caerphilly, I might have to try that next time.

    • crazymareranch says:

      Hi Ian you can get the gauge at Hoegger supply in the states-make sure you get the nut if you don’t have one on your press. It’s all very helpful!

  2. Your Caerphilly looks awesome! I like the simplicity of your press, I am thing of making a dutch cheese press, but may see about this style – it will be easier to store!

    • crazymareranch says:

      My first press I made and ordered the gauge from Toegger in the states. That way you get a very accurate measurement, and yes they break down easily! Good luck

  3. wow its great post..

  4. While I loved your post, I think I loved the photo of you on the counter with your cheese press. Oh, the honesty! Your cheese looks phenomenal and I cannot wait to hear the results of your effort. Do you typically make the caerphilly with your goat milk? Is this your first cow’s milk caerphilly? If so, I’d love to hear your comparison of a goat versus cow caerphilly, preferences, and any difference in technique or yield. Oh boy… now I sound demanding! I’m really not… just so very curious and excited!

    • crazymareranch says:

      Hi Christine, I’ve tasted both and I enjoy them both…best part is eating cheese after only three weeks(if it’s pasteurized milk). I found the yield to be quite amazing with the cows milk and I really loved working with the curd. Cows milk seems to have a bit larger curd, than the goats milk. I don’t often have the cows milk, but am toying with the idea of a jersey…just love the idea of butter, yogurt…it’s all great. Thanks for your comment.

  5. Well done, this post has been selected as one of the favourites for the December Challenge.


  1. […] at Crazy Mare Ranch from Barrhead Alberta Canada made Caerphilly and above is her finished product wrapped in cloth! […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: